JWST's Little Red Dots May Be Where the First Supermassive Black Holes Were Born
JWST's mysterious Little Red Dots may be young galaxies where the first supermassive black holes were born, hidden in thick discs of gas, a new simulation study suggests.

For four years, the Little Red Dots seen by the James Webb Space Telescope have been one of the strangest puzzles in astronomy. They are tiny, very red specks of light from the young universe that shine far brighter than their size should allow. A new study now offers one of the most complete explanations yet: they may be young galaxies where the first supermassive black holes were born, hidden inside thick discs of gas.
The work, led by Daniel Whalen of the University of Portsmouth in the UK, was published in The Astrophysical Journal Letters and announced on 10 November 2026. It uses detailed computer simulations of the early universe instead of new telescope images, and it reproduces several features of the dots that earlier ideas struggled to explain. Here is what the team found, how it fits with other recent studies, and what still has to be tested.
What are the Little Red Dots?
Little Red Dots, or LRDs, turned up in the very first deep images from the James Webb Space Telescope after it began science work in mid-2022. Survey teams soon found hundreds of them. According to the Portsmouth team, each one is only a few hundred light-years across, which is tiny for a galaxy, yet it can be as bright as galaxies many times larger.
Three things made them hard to explain:
- Their colour and shape of light. Their spectra have an unusual V shape: bright in the blue, dim in the middle and very bright again in the red.
- Missing X-rays. If a hungry black hole powered them, they should glow in X-rays. Most show little or no X-ray or radio emission.
- Their timing. They became common roughly 600 million years after the Big Bang and largely faded away by about 1.5 billion years.
"LRDs have been one of the most surprising discoveries made by the James Webb Space Telescope," Whalen, a senior lecturer at Portsmouth's Institute of Cosmology and Gravitation, said in the university's announcement.
Webb can see them only because it observes in infrared light and sits far from Earth's heat, about 1.5 million kilometres away. Our explainer on why JWST orbits at L2 covers why that matters, and our Hubble vs James Webb comparison shows why Hubble could not have spotted these objects.
What the new Little Red Dots simulations show
Whalen and colleagues ran advanced cosmological simulations that follow gas, stars and black holes as the first galaxies assemble. Their best match to the observations is a primeval galaxy whose central black hole formed when a supermassive primordial star collapsed. Primordial stars, also called Population III stars, were made almost purely of hydrogen and helium, and theory allows a rare few to grow to enormous masses before they collapse.
In the model, three pieces work together:
- A central black hole of about 10 million solar masses. That is well below earlier estimates, which ran as high as about 100 million solar masses.
- A thick disc of gas wrapped around it. The dense gas traps the high-energy X-rays near the black hole but lets some ultraviolet, visible and infrared light escape. That explains both the red glow and the missing X-rays.
- A crowded young star cluster. The disc also holds about 100 million stars packed into a region roughly 500 light-years wide. Their light supplies the blue half of the V-shaped spectrum.
The team says the model reproduces a wide range of LRDs, including some of the most distant and extreme examples found so far. "What makes this discovery so exciting is that we may be witnessing the birth of the first supermassive black holes," Whalen said.
Who worked on the study
Besides Portsmouth, the authors come from United Arab Emirates University, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki in Greece, the Institute for Astronomy at the University of Edinburgh and the Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian in the US. The paper is available through The Astrophysical Journal Letters, and the university's summary is on the University of Portsmouth news page.
Why the first supermassive black holes matter
Almost every large galaxy today, including our Milky Way, has a supermassive black hole at its centre. The hard part is timing. Webb and earlier telescopes have found black holes of millions to billions of solar masses less than a billion years after the Big Bang. Growing that big, that fast, from the remains of ordinary stars is very difficult.
A "heavy seed" helps. If some of the first black holes started at tens of thousands of solar masses or more, from the collapse of a supermassive star or a huge gas cloud, they would have a big head start. Researchers have proposed such seeds for decades, but they have been hard to catch in the act. If the Portsmouth model is right, Little Red Dots are that missing stage, caught while the newborn black hole is still wrapped in the gas that fed it.
"For decades, simulations have predicted that these objects should exist, and now the James Webb Space Telescope may finally be allowing us to see them," Whalen said.
How it compares with other Little Red Dots ideas
This is not the only explanation on the table, and the field has moved fast. Three other ideas from the past two years are worth knowing:
- Black holes in ionised gas cocoons. In January 2026, a team led from the Cosmic Dawn Center in Copenhagen reported in Nature that LRDs are young black holes about a hundred times less massive than first thought, surrounded by dense ionised gas that reshapes their light. The Portsmouth model also puts gas around a smaller black hole, but adds a specific way to form it and a star cluster for the blue light.
- Supermassive stars caught before collapse. Another group at the Center for Astrophysics has argued that some LRDs could be the giant primordial stars themselves, seen shortly before they collapse. The new study instead looks at what is left after that collapse.
- Unusual dark matter halos. In 2025, Fabio Pacucci and colleagues at the same centre suggested that LRDs form in slowly spinning dark matter halos, which would keep them small. "They are arguably the most surprising discovery by JWST to date," Pacucci said in the centre's 2025 release.
The explanations are not all rivals. Several agree that a smaller-than-expected black hole is buried in dense gas. They differ on how that black hole was born and what supplies the rest of the light.
What still needs to be tested
The Portsmouth result is a simulation, not a direct observation, and some key checks remain:
- Black hole masses. Webb spectra can be used to estimate black hole masses. If many LRDs turn out far heavier or lighter than about 10 million suns, the model will need changes.
- The star cluster. Deeper, sharper images could show whether the blue light really comes from a dense cluster of young stars.
- Why they vanish. A good model must explain why LRDs became rare after about 1.5 billion years, for example as the gas disc is used up or blown away.
- Numbers. Large surveys such as the Euclid mission's data releases and wide Webb surveys will show whether the model predicts the right number of LRDs at each cosmic age.
Little Red Dots are far too faint for any backyard telescope, wherever you live, because their light has travelled for more than 12 billion years. What you can do is follow the telescopes that find them. Our live James Webb tracker shows where Webb is now, and our recent story on Webb's most distant ring galaxy is another look at what Webb is revealing about the young universe.
For now, the dots are the best clue astronomers have about how giant black holes got started. If the new model holds up, Webb may already have photographed hundreds of them in their cradles.
More to read
All astronomy news →


From our guidesHubble vs James Webb: Orbits, Wavelengths and TrackingDeep Space · Aug 21, 2026
