Failed Supernova Clue: Many Black Holes May Come From Stars That Never Exploded

Hundreds of black hole mergers hint that many massive stars die without exploding. A new Caltech-led study links the 10-solar-mass peak to failed supernovae.

By SpaceTracker.live TeamPublished 8 min read
A huge orange star with swirling glowing layers spiralling inward toward a dark centre, wrapped in a faint dusty shell, with a spiral galaxy and scattered stars in the background
Artist's impression: AI illustration made with Google Gemini, edited by SpaceTracker.live Team. Not an actual photo.

Most massive stars are thought to die in a supernova, a blast that can outshine a whole galaxy for weeks. A new study suggests that many of them do not. By sorting through hundreds of black hole collisions picked up by gravitational-wave detectors, researchers have found signs that the most common black holes in these mergers, about 10 times the mass of the Sun, may come from a failed supernova: a star that collapsed into a black hole without exploding.

The paper, "Low-mass failed supernovae and the 10 M⊙ peak in the merging black hole mass distribution," was published in Physical Review D and announced by Caltech on 10 November 2026. It does not prove that failed supernovae happen. What it shows is that the gravitational-wave data fit that idea surprisingly well, and that astronomers now have a clear way to test it.

What is a failed supernova?

When a star many times heavier than the Sun runs out of fuel, its core collapses under its own weight. In the usual story, the collapse sends a shock wave out through the star, which blows most of the star's material into space as a supernova. A neutron star or a black hole is left behind.

A failed supernova skips the explosion. The core collapses, the shock wave stalls, and most of the star falls inward to form a black hole. From far away, the star does not flare up. It simply fades and disappears. Theorists have predicted such events for decades, but because there is no bright flash to spot, they are very hard to catch.

Failed supernova versus normal supernova, and the 10-solar-mass peak Left: two ways a massive star can die. In a normal supernova the star explodes, throws off most of its mass and leaves a small remnant. In a failed supernova the core collapses with no bright explosion and most of the star falls into a black hole of about 10 solar masses. Right: a simplified sketch of how often merging black holes of different masses are seen by gravitational-wave detectors, with a tall peak near 10 solar masses, a gap between about 12 and 16 solar masses, and a long tail of heavier black holes. Did these black holes skip the explosion? Two ways a massive star can die, and the clue hidden in black hole masses. Normal core-collapse supernova massive star bright explosion small remnant, most mass blown away Failed supernova (proposed) massive star core collapses, no bright blast black hole about 10 Suns The star simply seems to vanish. Hubble may have caught one: N6946-BH1 in the galaxy NGC 6946 disappeared between 2007 and 2015. Merging black holes seen so far simplified sketch, not the real data gap ~12-16 peak ~10 heavier black holes 510152535 black hole mass (Suns) how common About three-quarters of 257 mergers sit in the 10-Sun peak. Illustration: SpaceTracker.live Team. Based on Legred, Golomb and Chatziioannou, Physical Review D (2026), and Caltech. Peak shape is schematic.
A normal supernova blows most of a star away; a failed supernova leaves a heavier black hole behind. Right: a simplified sketch of the 10-solar-mass peak and the gap in merging black hole masses. Illustration: SpaceTracker.live Team.

The clue: a crowd of 10-solar-mass black holes

Since 2015, the LIGO detectors in the US, Virgo in Italy and KAGRA in Japan have recorded the faint ripples in space-time made when two black holes spiral together and merge. Each signal reveals the masses of the black holes involved. The network has now spotted more than 300 black hole collisions.

The Caltech-led team, led by Isaac Legred with Jacob Golomb and physics professor Katerina Chatziioannou, looked at 257 of these mergers from the past 10 years. Two features stood out:

  • A tall peak at about 10 solar masses. Roughly three-quarters of the black holes in the sample sit close to that value.
  • A gap just above it. Black holes between about 12 and 16 solar masses are noticeably rare.

"A vast majority of the merging black holes in the universe are about 10 times the mass of our Sun," said Chatziioannou, a member of the LIGO team, in the Caltech announcement.

"We see 10 solar-mass black holes merging all the time," added Legred, who did the work at Caltech and is now a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. "But why are, say, 14 solar-mass black holes so rare?"

How a failed supernova could explain the peak

The team's answer lies inside the stars. In their model, described in a Physics synopsis of the paper, stars that start out at roughly 12 to 14 solar masses have unusually compact cores. Those cores collapse straight into black holes with no supernova, and because the star keeps most of its mass, the result is reliably a black hole of about 10 solar masses.

Stars just a little lighter or heavier than that range do explode. The blast throws away almost all of their material, so they leave much smaller remnants. That would pile black holes up near 10 solar masses and leave few between about 12 and 16, which is what the detectors see.

"The gap we see in the distribution of masses indicates there may be a special cocktail of internal physics," Legred said.

The team also checked the black holes' spins, which carry hints about how they formed. The 10-solar-mass black holes spin within a narrower range than the full sample. "Our data are showing that this group of black holes may have a common origin," Chatziioannou said.

The limits of the result

The authors are clear that this is not direct proof. No failed supernova has been confirmed beyond doubt, and the study shows only that the merger data match what theory predicts. In Legred's words, the data are consistent with most binary black holes forming from a very special kind of failed supernova, "but more research is needed." The full paper is available through its DOI link at Physical Review D.

Stars that seem to have vanished

Gravitational waves are one route. The other is to look for stars that disappear. Two candidates stand out.

N6946-BH1. This red supergiant in the galaxy NGC 6946, about 22 million light-years away, brightened slightly in 2009 and then faded from view. Hubble images from 2007 and 2015 show the star present and then gone, and astronomers think it collapsed into a black hole.

M31-2014-DS1. This is the closest and best case so far. It sits in the Andromeda Galaxy, about 2.5 million light-years away. Kishalay De, an astronomer at Columbia University and the Simons Foundation's Flatiron Institute, and colleagues found it in archival data from NASA's NEOWISE mission and other telescopes. The star brightened in infrared light from 2014, then faded until it became undetectable in visible light, leaving only a faint glow from dust. The study was published in Science in February 2026.

"This star used to be one of the most luminous stars in the Andromeda Galaxy, and now it was nowhere to be seen," De said in a Simons Foundation release.

Reports put the Andromeda star at about a dozen times the Sun's mass. That is close to the 12 to 14 solar-mass range in the new model, although one star cannot prove a pattern. Legred sees this as the next step: "We can look up at the sky and try to study historical records of massive stars that failed to explode," he said.

Can you see where this happened?

The vanished star itself was always far too faint for the naked eye, but its home galaxy is easy to find. The Andromeda Galaxy is the most distant object most people can see without a telescope, and November evenings are a good time to look:

  • Around 40° to 50° north (New York, Madrid, Beijing, London, Berlin): Andromeda climbs almost overhead in the evening. From a dark site it looks like a faint, elongated smudge.
  • Around 25° to 35° north (Los Angeles, Cairo, Shanghai, Tokyo): very high in the evening sky, close to overhead later in the night.
  • The tropics (Mexico City, Lagos, Singapore): well placed in the northern sky during the evening.
  • Around 33° to 35° south (Sydney, Cape Town, Santiago): only about 15° above the northern horizon at best, so you need a clear, low view to the north.

Our Andromeda Galaxy guide shows where M31 is in your sky tonight, and the live planetarium lets you check the view from anywhere in the world.

What comes next

Each new observing run adds more mergers, which will show whether the 10-solar-mass peak and the gap above it stay sharp. If they do, the failed-supernova idea gets stronger. At the same time, sky surveys that watch the same galaxies over many years, such as the Vera C. Rubin Observatory in Chile, should catch more stars that fade away without exploding.

If both lines of evidence point the same way, it would change how astronomers think about the deaths of stars. Some of the black holes now merging across the universe may have been born not in fireworks but in silence. For more on how dead and dying stars behave, see our recent stories on a dead star sending radio pulses every 8 minutes and the Blaze Star's long-awaited outburst.

Source: Caltech / Physical Review D ↗

#Failed Supernova#Black Holes#Gravitational Waves#LIGO#Virgo#KAGRA#Andromeda Galaxy#Massive Stars
Share:WhatsAppXFacebook